Rare Book Monthly

Articles - October - 2024 Issue

The Bancroft Library Considers Changing Its Name.

Hubert Howe Bancroft.

Hubert Howe Bancroft.

We are living in a time when some buildings, monuments and places are having their names changed. They are structures and places named in another era for the notable persons of their time. They were generally highly respected individuals. However, looking back, with the benefit of better understandings and greater sensitivity, they no longer look quite so heroic. Some held decidedly offensive views, though in their time, they were commonplace. One such individual was Hubert Howe Bancroft. His name adorns one of America's most respected libraries, the University of California at Berkeley's Bancroft Library. Some people want that name changed.

 

Hubert Howe Bancroft was a book publisher. He came from Ohio to California in the early 1850s and within a decade, was the largest publisher in the West. He evidently did quite well financially as he retired in his prime and began writing and collecting books. He took on a major project – a history of the American West. It encompasses 39 volumes, took many years and writers to complete, and even today is considered an essential source for information about the West in its youth. It was not notably scholarly by today's standards, with opinion mixed in with facts, but the amount of information is remarkable for its time. Bancroft did receive some criticism back then, though not for objectivity and sensitivity. It was for failing to give the writers who assisted him in the venture their due credit.

 

In time, Bancroft's personal collection grew and grew. By the time he concluded it should be sold, it contained something in the area of 60,000 volumes. He put them up for sale at a price of $250,000. There were no takers. The state of California turned him down. Over several years it languished. Eventually, he got an appraisal for $300,000. Finally, he offered it to the state again, still for the $250,000 price, but Bancroft made the choice easier this time. He contributed $100,000 of his own money toward the purchase. In return, he expected the library housing it would bear the Bancroft name. California accepted.

 

I have not read Bancroft's 39 volumes (nor any of them) so I cannot make statements from personal knowledge, but apparently there are sections in there that are quite racist. In describing his collection, the Bancroft Library website says, “NOTE: The Library acknowledges the controversial legacy of Hubert Howe Bancroft whose writings and published works exhibit damaging and racist views, particularly against Indigenous, Asian, and African American communities. This section is not intended to glorify the man, but rather highlight the historical value and importance of the collection he amassed.”

 

Bancroft evidently held what was a common point of view at the time by White, European descended males – White, European males were racially, sexually, and ethnically superior to persons not sharing those attributes. A comment from Bancroft in one of his volumes, quoted in Smithsonian Magazine, says, “Several women were also employed upon these voyages [writing the texts]. I know not why it is, but almost every attempt to employ female talent in connection with these industries has proved a signal failure. I have today nothing to show for thousands of dollars paid out for the futile attempts of female writers…If she have genius, let her stay at home, write from her effervescent brain, and sell the product to the highest bidder.” To say that is sexist would be the understatement of 2024, but obviously Bancroft could not see it. It's hard to understand why he could not, but Bancroft lived in different times, when others were equally obtuse.

 

It's worth pointing out here that even Lincoln said Blacks were not equal in “all respects,” though equal in the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. That was exceptional then, but today it wouldn't fly. Ashley A. Bancroft, Hubert Howe's father, was an early leader in the abolitionist movement in Ohio. His house was a stop on the Underground Railroad, and Hubert may have assisted in moving escaped slaves north hidden in a hay wagon. It is hard to imagine he was not in favor of abolition and rights for Black people like Lincoln. It was not inconsistent at that time to be a strong defender of black freedom while still having disdain for the people themselves. It sounds like Hubert Bancroft may have fit that model.

 

A couple of years ago, a student became aware of Bancroft's past statements and petitioned the university to change the library's name. A group was formed to consider the request called the Bancroft Library Reckoning Committee. Several public hearings were scheduled which by this time should have already taken place. These cases can be hard to decide. Bancroft was a generous if bigoted man. His gift made the library possible. I don't know how bad his level of insensitivity was, but my own feelings are that if his sentiments were typical of his time, his generosity should not be eradicated from history. I believe their views would be like ours if they were born today. Washington owned slaves, but I am certain he wouldn't want to own slaves if he were alive today. We have the benefit of hindsight; they don't. On the other hand, if he was offensive even for that era, he probably would be the same today and his name should go.

 

Berkeley, the city and university, are named after Bishop George Berkeley, who owned slaves and called Indians “savages.” He advocated kidnapping Indian children to convert them to Christianity. We would not be naming our cities and colleges for him today, but this was almost 300 years ago and it is especially hard to rename a city or university all these years later. Think of all the places named after Christopher Columbus, yet he was a terrible person even by the standards of his time. His fellow slave owners thought him brutal.

 

In writing about the West, Bancroft interviewed John Evans. Like Bancroft, Evans came west from Ohio. He became Governor of Colorado, and did many good things, including being a founder of Northwestern University and the University of Denver. On the other hand, Evans ordered the local militia to go out and kill as many Indians as they could find. The Sand Creek Massacre is also part of his legacy. Evans told Bancroft that he converted from Quakerism to Methodism so he could kill Indians (no, Methodists don't advocate killing Indians but they aren't total pacifists like Quakers). Mt. Evans, whose peak is reached via the highest paved road in America, was named for Gov. Evans. It isn't any more. It is now Mt. Blue Sky, as it was originally known to native tribes. Bancroft wasn't Evans, but not Martin Luther King either. He is one of those many people somewhere in between, and each community will have to decide for itself how to handle places named for them.


Posted On: 2024-10-01 04:47
User Name: keeline

Surely you mean "Martin Luther King, Jr." There were two people who shared the name. One is famous.

James D. Keeline


Posted On: 2024-10-01 05:22
User Name: faulhaber

Hi Michael,
Would you be willing to submit this as a public comment on the Bancroft Reckoning Committee's website: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScPEnb1ns8EGrZKJrzJGqQzC5YkCpcSFkeS47k6UJnHttS8Pw/viewform
This is the kind of balanced assessment that the members of the committee need to see.
Thanks,
Charles Faulhaber
Director Emeritus, The Bancroft Library
P.S. If you can't navigate the website I'm pretty sure that I can make it available to the committee


Posted On: 2024-10-01 14:41
User Name: ae244155

Charles,
Thank you for the kind comments. I wouldn't submit something to the Reckoning Committee as I don't think it's my appropriate role to become so involved, though I certainly don't mind the thoughts being brought to their consideration.
Mike


Posted On: 2024-10-01 17:50
User Name: faulhaber

Thanks, Michael,
I will make sure that the committee sees this.
Charles


Rare Book Monthly

  • Bonhams, now to Oct. 24: CATESBY, MARK. 1683-1749. The Natural History of Carolina, Florida, and the Bahama Islands. $100,000 - $150,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 24: AUDUBON, JOHN JAMES. 1785-1851. The Birds of America, from Drawings Made in the United States and their Territories. $30,000 - $50,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 24: ADAMS ON HIS PEAR TREES AND A LOST PORTRAIT BY SALEM ARTIST HANNAH CROWNINSHIELD. ADAMS, JOHN. 1735-1826. $10,000 - $15,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 24: EARLIEST MAP DEVOTED TO NORTH AMERICA. FORLANI, PAULO. fl.1560-1571. $20,000 - $30,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 24: HAMILTON DEFENDS THE CONSTITUTION. HAMILTON, ALEXANDER. 1757-1804. $20,000 - $30,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 24: NO TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION BROADSIDE. Boston, September 14, 1768. $5,000 - $8,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 23: ONE OF THE EARLIEST ILLUSTRATIONS OF A SURGICAL PROCEDURE. BARTHOLOMAEUS ANGLICUS. $10,000 - $15,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 23: RICHARD FEYNMAN'S ANNOTATED COPY, WITH TWO EARLY FEYNMAN AUTOGRAPH MANUSCRIPTS. $15,000 - $25,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 23: THE FOUNDATIONS OF MODERN COMPUTING. TURING, ALAN MATHISON. 1912-1954. $30,000 - $50,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 23: FINE OIL PORTRAIT OF ALBERT EINSTEIN BY EUGEN SPIRO. $40,000 - $60,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 23: PENICILLIN MOLD MEDALLION INSCRIBED BY ALEXANDER FLEMING. FLEMING, ALEXANDER. 1881-1955. $30,000 - $50,000
    Bonhams, now to Oct. 23: APPLE "TWIGGY" MACINTOSH PROTOTYPE USED IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF DEMONSTRATION SOFTWARE. $80,000 - $120,000
  • One of a Kind Collectibles Auctions
    Rare Autograph and Book Auction
    October 17th, 2024
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: Abraham Lincoln Signed Letter on Executive Mansion Stationary To Secretary of The Navy re: Appointment for Naval Academy!
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: Extremely Rare Ben Franklin Printed: Considerations on Keeping Negroes...Part Second. 1762.
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: An impressively extra-illustrated copy; Including an Original leaf from Shakespeare’s 1623 First Folio!
    One of a Kind Collectibles Auctions
    Rare Autograph and Book Auction
    October 17th, 2024
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: Rarest Naval Autograph James Lawrence “Don’t give up the ship On " U.S. Ship Hornet June 19th 1812.
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: Oversize Ernest Hemingway Signed Photo with long Inscription about Drinking Wine to his dear friend and Secretary Roberto Herrera.
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: VOLTAIRE Signed Receipt about a partial payment of debt for the Duke of Wuerttemberg.
    One of a Kind Collectibles Auctions
    Rare Autograph and Book Auction
    October 17th, 2024
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: [Maps] Gio. Ant. Magnini, Italia, 1620.
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: LAWMAN SALOON JUDGE ROY BEAN Signed Legal Document 1895-RARE!
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: Autograph Album with James Garfield as President, Chester A. Aurthur as VP, William T. Sherman, Burnside, P.T. Barnum and many more!
    One of a Kind Collectibles Auctions
    Rare Autograph and Book Auction
    October 17th, 2024
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: Thomas Jefferson and James Madison Signed Four Language Ship's Paper.
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: Hector Berlioz Autograph Musical Quotation Signed.
    One of a Kind Collectibles, Oct. 17: Important Memorandum the Day after Gettysburg July 5th, 1863 where Lincoln asks all Department Heads of the cabinet to meet him at the Executive Mansion.
  • RareBookBuyer.com
    We Buy Librairies & Rare Books Nationwide
    ABAA Dealer
    RareBookBuyer.com
    Specialized in Purchasing
    Institutional Collections & Deacccessioned Books
    RareBookBuyer.com
    We Buy Librairies & Rare Books Nationwide
    ABAA Dealer
    RareBookBuyer.com
    Specialized in Purchasing
    Institutional Collections & Deacccessioned Books
    RareBookBuyer.com
    We Buy Librairies & Rare Books Nationwide
    ABAA Dealer
    RareBookBuyer.com
    Specialized in Purchasing
    Institutional Collections & Deacccessioned Books
    RareBookBuyer.com
    We Buy Librairies & Rare Books Nationwide
    ABAA Dealer
    RareBookBuyer.com
    Specialized in Purchasing
    Institutional Collections & Deacccessioned Books
    RareBookBuyer.com
    We Buy Librairies & Rare Books Nationwide
    ABAA Dealer
  • Sotheby’s
    Bibliotheca Brookeriana:
    A Renaissance Library. The Aldine Collection D-M
    18 October 2024
    Sotheby’s, Oct. 18: Herodianus Syrus, Herodiani Historiarum, Venice, Heirs of Aldo & Torresano, 1524, Parisian binding for Jean Grolier by Jean Picard, ca. 1540
    Sotheby’s, Oct. 18: Musaeus, Opusculum de Herone et Leandro, Venice, Aldo, 1495 (Greek text), interleaved with 1497–1498 (Latin text), English olive morocco by Charles Lewis, the Botfield copy
    Sotheby’s, Oct. 18: Horatius Flaccus, Horatius, Venice, Aldo, 1501, Bolognese brown goatskin (between 1501 and 1503), arms of Mino Rossi and illuminated initials throughout
    Sotheby’s, Oct. 18: Lucretius, De rerum natura, Venice, Aldo, 1500, English early eighteenth-century red morocco, the Fletcher copy
    Sotheby’s, Oct. 18: Dante, Le terze rime, Venice, Aldo, 1502, illuminated, contemporary Bolognese morocco binding

Article Search

Archived Articles

Ask Questions