Rare Book Monthly

Articles - March - 2022 Issue

The Changing Economics of Rare Paper Auctions

In my February 2022 article for RBH, we parsed out the numbers from last year to understand if and how change is occurring within the auction markets for rare books, prints and ephemera. From analyzing the charts (www.rarebookhub.com/articles/3135) we were able to determine a concentration of auction houses hosting the bulk of auction events, resulting in an increase of supply through the market.

 

More lots are out there than ever before, however competition is tight and the profitability of each auction event has never been more crucial for auction houses caught in the middle range of the market.

 

This article will look at the micro-level of the auction event itself to provide an analysis of the economics of the auction event in order to understand emerging trends and tendency within the market. If you are going to work with auction houses, best know how they make money.

(www.rarebookhub.com/articles/3044)

 

 

 

The graph provided imagines the revenue and cost curves of two distinct auction events, the Value Model (#1) and the Volume Model (#2).

 

Revenue curves

 

The revenue curves are generated by multiplying the Gross Auction Value by the seller’s commission and the buyer’s premium and adding any service revenues that might occur. Gross Transaction Value (GTV) represents total proceeds from all items sold at the auction houses’ in person auctions, and online marketplaces.  Auction Revenue is generally 15-30% of the Gross Auction Value.

 

The angle of each revenue curve provides insights into the average value of each lot offered in the auction, with the steeper curve of the Value Model being indicative of an auction event with higher value items and the shallower curve of the Volume Model being an auction event containing lower value items.  The Value Model, because there is a higher contribution to profit per lot, has a lower breakeven point (the point in an auction event where all fixed costs are covered by revenues) than that of the Volume Model.  As shown in the graphic, the Value Model is profitable (the point at which the revenue line exceeds the Total Cost curve) with the sale of many fewer lots (150-175 lots) than the Volume Model (300-325 lots).  In reality, the Revenue Curves are indicative of two different auction event business models.

 

Cost curves

 

Some of the costs for an auction event are fixed and some costs are variable. The fixed costs of an auction event, usually allocated from a pool of fixed costs from the auction houses, do not vary as a function of the number of lots presented or lots sold. Big drivers of fixed cost in any auction business are facilities costs and the salaries of staff.  As you can see from the graphic, the Fixed Cost curve is flat, and does not vary across all numbers of lots; both Value and Volume Models face the same fixed cost of the event.

 

Variable Costs relate to a specific auction and can include unique auction event marketing, product acquisition costs and specific staffing requirements driven by the auction event.  As you can see from the graphic, the variable costs layer on top of the fixed cost to provide a Total Cost line.

 

As previously noted, Profit (Total Revenue greater than Total Cost) for the Value Model occurs at 150-175 lots, while the Volume Model require the sale of 300-325 lots to be profitable.  These are two different auctions likely held by two auction houses with differing business models and strategies.

 

Event Profitability

 

Each auction event has a profit dynamic. In order to increase revenue an auction house needs to increase Gross Transaction Value (GTV). This can be achieved by either increasing the number of units offered or increasing the unit value of items offered. The Volume Model’s draw being a confluence of many, lower prices lots resulting in an increased sell thru rate (STR), the Value Model’s draw being the showcasing of a few, rare items to achieve the same GTV objective.

 

Another way to increase profitability of an auction event is through increasing revenue per unit by increasing either the seller’s commission or buyer’s commission (or both). This can be justified if evidence of high STRs can be demonstrated, supported by an infrastructure of client management programs and multi-prong marketing campaigns.

 

At the same time, decreasing costs by reducing variable costs per unit and/or reducing fixed costs need to be continually reassessed by the auction house. For example, a major method by which to reduce auction event cost levels is by transitioning auction events from in-person to online formats. We saw this prior to the Pandemic by a few auction houses, then almost ubiquitously during.  This digital transformation of the auction industry is likely structural meaning that we will not likely completely return to the “old way” of heavy reliance on in-person auction events.  As a result, many auction event costs will be permanently driven downwards.

 

Auction business profitability moving forward

 

An auction business is a portfolio of individual auction events. Not all auction events need to be profitable, but the portfolio of auction events when consolidated over the year needs to be or the auction house will not survive. As was observed in the previous article, there are many more in the ecosystem, mostly in the low/mid-price range.

 

At present, within each auction event and after, auction houses running a legitimate growth strategy are seeking to increase the revenue per event, decrease the variable costs per event and decrease the fixed costs per event.

 

Moving forward, the following responses are indicative of auction organizing adapting to the structural changes underway:

 

Commission percentages paid by both Buyers and Sellers will likely continue to rise with more services invented and delivered to augment auction revenues.

 

On-line auction events will become the rule rather than the exception as all auction houses seek to drop the level of fixed and variable costs in their operations. Sizes of auction events (number of lots offered) will continue to increase until an “optimum event size” is discovered that maximizes profit per event.

 

The number of auction events per auction house will continue to increase in order to spread fixed costs over more auction events.  This will continue subject to the constraints of consignment availability and the willingness of auction houses to invest in new, expanded infrastructure (i.e. online platforms and further intelligence toward targeted marketing of yet unidentified collector clients).

 

Investors will likely get an opportunity to invest in the publicly listed shares of auction houses as established firms such as Sotheby’s (again) go public (https://news.artnet.com/market/sothebys-takes-another-step-ipo-2060295) or K Auctions in South Korea (http://www.koreaherald.com/view.php?ud=20220113000959&np=1&mp=1) to raise money to grow and expand infrastructure and venture backed auction houses, such as Catawiki, go public to create liquidity for the original investors.

 

The forces impacting the rare book auction market are bigger than books. The economic drivers as outline above seem unfamiliar because they are originating from areas of the economy (Capital Markets, Digital technology, Social Media marketing and Cloud-based auction platforms) that have not historically played a major role in rare book, manuscript, and ephemera ecosystems. However once introduced, these forces have permanent impacts on the bottom lines of auction houses and the services they provide Collectors and the Trade.

 

About Spencer W Stuart
 
Spencer W Stuart provides analytic services to collectors and dealers using auctions to build their collections and inventory. For Dealers, Spencer provides consulting services to develop hybrid or total transitions of book business to the use of auction mechanisms as a growth strategy.
 
In concert with his advising, Spencer is an active writer and lecturer on histories of the printed word for a variety of publications including The Book Collector and Amphora as well as with the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.

Rare Book Monthly

  • Forum Auctions
    Books, Manuscripts and Works on Paper
    28th March 2024
    Forum Mar. 28: [Langland (William)]. The vision of Pierce Plowman, nowe the seconde time imprinted..., Roberte Crowley, 1550. £8,000 to £10,000.
    Forum Mar. 28: [Shakespeare (William)]. [Comedies, Histories, and Tragedies], second folio edition, [by Tho.Cotes, for Robert Allot], [1632]. £30,000 to £40,000.
    Forum Mar. 28: Bible, Czech Biblia Bohemica, first complete Bible printed in the Czech vernacular, Prague, August 1488. £30,000 to £40,000.
    Forum Auctions
    Books, Manuscripts and Works on Paper
    28th March 2024
    Forum Mar. 28: Shabthai Tzvi.- Collection of four printed and illustrated broadsides detailing the appearance, rise and fall of the false messiah, Shabthai Tzvi, Augsburg, 1666-67. £40,000 to £60,000.
    Forum Mar. 28: Leaf from the Beauvais Missal, in Latin, illuminated manuscript on parchment, [Northern France (perhaps Beauvais or Amiens)], [fourteenth century (c.1310)]. £4,000 to £6,000.
    Forum Mar. 28: Aubrey (John). [Remaines of Gentilisme and Judaisme], manuscript in English, Latin and Greek, [c. 1693]. £30,000 to £50,000.
    Forum Auctions
    Books, Manuscripts and Works on Paper
    28th March 2024
    Forum Mar. 28: Byron (George Gordon Noel, Lord). Poems on Various Occasions, first edition, Harriet Maltby's copy, Newark, Printed by S. & J. Ridge, 1807. £30,000 to £40,000.
    Forum Mar. 28: Tolkien (J.R.R.) The Hobbit, first edition, second impression with dust-jacket, 1937 [but 1938]. £7,000 to £10,000.
    Forum Mar. 28: Blake (William).- Thornton (Robert John). The Pastorals of Virgil, 2 vol., engraved plates by William Blake, 1821. £8,000 to £12,000.
    Forum Auctions
    Books, Manuscripts and Works on Paper
    28th March 2024
    Forum Mar. 28: America.- Mount (William J.) & Thomas Page. The English Pilot…, [bound with] The Fourth Book, describing The West Indies Navigation from Hudson's-Bay to the River Amazones, 1721. £20,000 to £30,000.
    Forum Mar. 28: Oldfield (Henry Ambrose), Rajman Singh Chitrakar & others. An album of 160 photographs and 13 original artworks, (1833-1919), [c. 1850s-1880s]. £20,000 to £30,000.
    Forum Mar. 28: Audubon (John James) [and William MacGillivray]. Ornithological Biography…, 5 vol., first edition, presentation copy inscribed by Audubon, Edinburgh, 1831-49 [i.e. 1831-39]. £10,000 to £15,000.
  • Sotheby’s
    Modern First Editions
    Available for Immediate Purchase
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: Winston Churchill. The Second World War. Set of First-Edition Volumes. 6,000 USD
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: A.A. Milne, Ernest H. Shepard. A Collection of The Pooh Books. Set of First-Editions. 18,600 USD
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: Salvador Dalí, Lewis Carroll. Alice's Adventures in Wonderland. Finely Bound and Signed Limited Edition. 15,000 USD
    Sotheby’s
    Modern First Editions
    Available for Immediate Purchase
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: Ian Fleming. Live and Let Die. First Edition. 9,500 USD
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: J.K. Rowling. Harry Potter Series. Finely Bound First Printing Set of Complete Series. 5,650 USD
    Sotheby’s, Available Now: Ernest Hemingway. A Farewell to Arms. First Edition, First Printing. 4,200 USD
  • Bonhams, Mar. 22 – Apr. 2: A RUTH BADER GINSBURG BEADED JUDICIAL COLLAR. $80,000 - $120,000
    Bonhams, Mar. 22 – Apr. 2: ONLY KNOWN COPY OF THE ONLY BOOK BY THE REMARKABLE EVE ADAMS. $8,000 - $12,000
    Bonhams, Mar. 22 – Apr. 2: A COMPLETE RUN OF VISIONAIRE MAGAZINE THROUGH 2010. $6,000 - $9,000
    Bonhams, Mar. 22 – Apr. 2: LAW REVIEW OFFPRINT SIGNED AND INSCRIBED BY RUTH BADER GINSBURG. $3,000 - $5,000
    Bonhams, Mar. 22 – Apr. 2: META REBNER'S WORKING SCRIPT OF THE LOVED ONE. $1,500 - $2,000
    Bonhams, Mar. 22 – Apr. 2: A KATHY GROVE PORTRAIT OF CYNDI LAUPER FOR THE FEBRUARY 1989 DETAILS COVER. $800 - $1,200
    Bonhams, Mar. 22 – Apr. 2: A PLASTIC COAT BY MILLIE DAVID FEATURED IN SOHO NEWS STYLE SECTION, FROM THE COLLECTION OF ANNIE FLANDERS. $500 - $700
    Bonhams, Mar. 22 – Apr. 2: A RUTH BADER GINSBURG JEWELRY BOX. $600 - $900
    Bonhams, Mar. 22 – Apr. 2: A SET OF JONI MITCHELL LYRICS FOR "IF I HAD A HEART." $2,000 - $3,000
  • 19th Century Shop
    Catalogue 198 just published
    19th Century Shop. Darwin and Wallace, first printing of the first paper on natural selection
    19th Century Shop. Shakespeare’s Poems, first collected edition
    19th Century Shop. Walt Whitman portrait inscribed with a Leaves of Grass poem
    19th Century Shop. Major Elizabeth Barrett Browning manuscript notebook
    19th Century Shop. Spock's Baby Book, original MS
    19th Century Shop. Cellarius, Harmonia Macrocosmica, the great celestial atlas
  • Potter & Potter Auctions
    How History Unfolds on Paper:
    Choice Selections from the Eric C. Caren Collection
    Part IX
    April 18, 2024
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: [RUTH, George Herman “Babe” (1895-1948)]. Signed photograph. Circa 1930s. 191 x 248 mm. $1,500 to $2,500.
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: HARRISON, Benjamin. Document signed (“Benj Harrison”) as governor of Virginia, certifying the service of Daniel Cumbo, a Black Revolutionary soldier. $6,000 to $9,000.
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: ONE OF THE FIRST PRINTED ANNOUNCEMENTS OF THE DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE. $4,000 to $6,000.
    Potter & Potter Auctions
    How History Unfolds on Paper:
    Choice Selections from the Eric C. Caren Collection
    Part IX
    April 18, 2024
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: FIRST PRINTING OF LINCOLN’S IMMORTAL GETTYSBURG ADDRESS. $4,000 to $6,000.
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: HIGHLY IMPORTANT MORMON ARCHIVE. ALLEY, George. Archive of 23 Autograph Letters Signed by Mormon Convert George Alley to His Brother Joseph Alley. $10,000 to $20,000.
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: [AVIATION]. [ARMSTRONG, Neil A.] Aviation Hall of Fame Gold Medal MS64 NGC, Awarded to Neil Armstrong in 1979. $2,000 to $3,000.
    Potter & Potter Auctions
    How History Unfolds on Paper:
    Choice Selections from the Eric C. Caren Collection
    Part IX
    April 18, 2024
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: NEWLY DISCOVERED FIRST PRINTING OF "WITH MALICE TOWARDS NONE... " FROM THE ONLY NEWSPAPER ACTUALLY ALLOWED TO PARTICIPATE IN LINCOLN’S SECOND INAUGURAL PROCESSION. $4,000 to $8,000.
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: THE MOST IMPORTANT GEORGE WASHINGTON DOCUMENT IN PRIVATE HANDS; GEORGE WASHINGTON’S COMMISSION AS COMMANDER IN CHIEF, 1775, ONE OF ONLY TWO ORIGINALS. $150,000 to $250,000.
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: A VERY RARE ACCOUNT OF BLACKBEARD’S DEATH AND ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT PIRATE ITEMS EXTANT. $3,000 to $5,000.
    Potter & Potter Auctions
    How History Unfolds on Paper:
    Choice Selections from the Eric C. Caren Collection
    Part IX
    April 18, 2024
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: EDISON, Thomas. Patent for Edison’s Improvements on the Electric-Light, No. 219,628. [Washington, D.C.: U.S. Patent Office], 16 September 1879. $2,000 to $3,000.
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: [VIETNAM WAR]. The original pen used by Secretary of State William P. Rogers to sign the Vietnam Peace Agreement, Paris, 27 January 1973. $10,000 to $15,000.
    Potter & Potter, Apr. 18: SONS OF LIBERTY FOUNDER COLONEL BARRÉ ANNOTATED TITLE-PAGE, “WHICH OUGHT TO ROUSE UP BRITISH ATTENTION”. $4,000 to $6,000.

Article Search

Archived Articles

Ask Questions