Along with the above call there was a letter, in Mr. Robinson’s hand, which throws important light upon this initiatory transaction. My history will chiefly be made up of the epistles of Orrin Robinson, who invariably writes straight out what he means to say, and then stops. His style is clear, direct, and to the point. So much, by the way of apology, for doing what may make the author better known than he cares to be, in a transaction that does not belong so directly to him as it is my business.

Elmira April 19, 1851

Rev. and Dear Sir.

I received yours of Tuesday last evening, containing the sad intelligence of your disaster by fire. We had previously heard, by telegraph and papers, the fact, and were not entirely unprepared for a result such as you came to in relation to remaining at Catskill on next Sabbath. Though sadly disappointed, I think our people will yield submissively, and without a murmur acquiesce in this dispensation. We deeply sympathize with you, and your family; and only regret that we are not placed in a situation to minister to your necessities in this time of need and trial. This dispensation, to us, may look dark and mysterious; but one sentiment of the poet should silence all curiosity –

“Behind a frowning Providence,
He hides a smiling face.”

The meeting of our church and congregation on Tuesday, was better attended, considering the number absent, than I anticipated. There was first a church meeting, when a vote of all, male and female members, was taken; which was unanimous. At this meeting of the church and congregation, the males only votes. One man was excused from voting. Every other vote was cast for you, and every man responded to his name. This was harmony beyond my expectations. The number of votes I do not know. We put the salary at a $1,000, beside the Parsonage, as under all circumstances, the Committee deemed it hazardous to name a larger amount to start with. The Parsonage house and garden would rent any day for $300; so, in fact, it is a salary of $1,300. In the call phrase “Parsonage House and Lot” is meant to include, of course, all the appurtenances, consisting of Barn, Shed, and Woodhouse, etc. As I have before stated to you, our salary is promptly collected, and paid, when due, or nearly so but few days intervening. Should you accept our call, a question of great moment to us arises, When can you come? Our house is ready, the garden wants a dresser; our people are ready to receive you, and to assist you. Should you prefer to come and see us before deciding the case, we should like to see you as soon as you can conveniently come. Please let us know when we may expect you. If you desire any information which I have omitted, I shall be happy to furnish it. The vote of the meeting was that the Trustees sign the call. Enclosed I send it signed by all Trustees, except one, who is in Boston. I am, in bonds of Christian affection,

Truly yours, in behalf of the Committee,
Orrin Robinson